Renters Insurance AI Visibility Ranking Trends - November 2026

Tracking how AI platforms recommend renters insurance ai visibility ranking trends. Updated monthly since April 2026.

Mark Huntley, J.D.
By Mark Huntley, J.D.Growth Strategist & AI Discovery Analyst
14 minutes read
Browse 1 archived editions

Answer capsule

The November 2026 Renters Insurance benchmark compares 10 companies across 80 AI answers that met its inclusion rules. Lemonade, State Farm share the lead with 59 recommendations each (73.75% of answers). At least one tracked company was recommended in 61 answers; some answers recommended several companies.

The rankings distinguish being mentioned from receiving an affirmative recommendation, then examine placement and the wording used about each company. This edition establishes a baseline; earlier editions measured on a different basis are not used to claim a performance trend. These results describe the answers reviewed, not product quality or customer satisfaction. Differences between monthly samples limit comparisons and do not establish why a result changed.

For the strategic interpretation of this benchmark, read CiteWorks Studio's analysis of How AI Search Is Recommending Renters Insurance

Industry leaderboard

Questions This Section Answers

  • How do Renters Insurance rank by recorded AI recommendations in November 2026?

Rank

Company

Recommendations

Recommendation rate

Mention rate

Top 3 rate

#1 rate

Net sentiment

1

Lemonade

59

73.75%

90.00%

51.25%

6.25%

0.83

1

State Farm

59

73.75%

100.00%

68.75%

31.25%

0.76

3

USAA

56

70.00%

95.00%

35.00%

12.50%

0.75

4

Amica

48

60.00%

67.50%

41.25%

18.75%

0.89

5

Allstate

37

46.25%

90.00%

8.75%

0.00%

0.51

6

Nationwide

34

42.50%

72.50%

3.75%

1.25%

0.59

7

Travelers

23

28.75%

46.25%

6.25%

2.50%

0.62

8

Progressive

18

22.50%

67.50%

6.25%

0.00%

0.31

9

American Family Insurance

5

6.25%

12.50%

1.25%

0.00%

0.50

10

Farmers

4

5.00%

27.50%

0.00%

0.00%

0.14

The leaderboard orders companies by how many recorded answers included an affirmative recommendation. Lemonade and State Farm share first place because their recommendation counts are equal; the tie is a tie, not a hidden winner. A mention only means the company appeared in an answer, while a recommendation requires endorsement. Placement sits inside recommendations, so first-place and shortlist counts are subsets rather than extra credit.

Key findings

Tracked-company answer coverage

Questions This Section Answers

  • How often did the November 2026 Renters Insurance answer sample recommend any tracked company?

Answer-level result

Qualified answers

Share of qualified answers

At least one tracked company mentioned

80

100.00%

At least one tracked company recommended

61

76.25%

No tracked company recommended

19

23.75%

Multiple tracked companies recommended

61

76.25%

61 distinct answers recommended at least one tracked company. Counting each company recommendation separately gives 343, because an answer can recommend several companies. Answers with no tracked recommendation may still have recommended companies outside this comparison.

Every qualified answer named at least one tracked company, but fewer carried a recommendation for one. Most answers recommended more than one tracked company, which is why company-level recommendation counts sum well above the number of answers. Overlap is expected and does not indicate market dominance. Answers without a tracked recommendation may still have named companies outside this comparison.

Reach and affirmative recommendation

Lemonade ranks 1 by recommendation count. Mentions: 72 (90.00%); recommendations: 59 (73.75%). Top 3 placements: 41 (51.25%); first-place placements: 5 (6.25%).

Wording about the company: 60 positive, 12 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 81.9%. The net framing score was 0.83 (defined in Methodology).

13 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 69.49% were Top 3 and 8.47% were first-place.

State Farm ranks 1 by recommendation count. Mentions: 80 (100.00%); recommendations: 59 (73.75%). Top 3 placements: 55 (68.75%); first-place placements: 25 (31.25%).

Wording about the company: 61 positive, 19 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 73.8%. The net framing score was 0.76 (defined in Methodology).

21 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 93.22% were Top 3 and 42.37% were first-place.

Lemonade and State Farm tie on recommendation count, yet their reach differs: State Farm appeared in every qualified answer, Lemonade in most. Mention presence and affirmative endorsement answer different questions, so a high mention rate does not guarantee a recommendation. The share of mentions that also carried a recommendation is a description of recorded wording, not a conversion measure.

Recommendation order and placement

Company

Mentions

Recommendation-to-mention ratio

Top 3 / #1 counts

Positive / neutral / negative mentions

Lemonade

72

81.9%

41 / 5

60 / 12 / 0

State Farm

80

73.8%

55 / 25

61 / 19 / 0

USAA

76

73.7%

28 / 10

57 / 19 / 0

Amica

54

88.9%

33 / 15

48 / 6 / 0

Allstate

72

51.4%

7 / 0

37 / 35 / 0

Nationwide

58

58.6%

3 / 1

34 / 24 / 0

Travelers

37

62.2%

5 / 2

23 / 14 / 0

Progressive

54

33.3%

5 / 0

18 / 35 / 1

American Family Insurance

10

50.0%

1 / 0

5 / 5 / 0

Farmers

22

18.2%

0 / 0

4 / 17 / 1

Placement describes where a recommended company sat in the answer's ordering. Shortlist and first-place counts are nested within recommendations, so they should not be added to recommendation totals. A company can be recommended often while rarely appearing near the top, and another can be placed highly within a smaller recommendation base.

Classified framing in context

Company

Positive

Neutral

Negative

Lemonade

60

12

0

State Farm

61

19

0

USAA

57

19

0

Amica

48

6

0

Allstate

37

35

0

Nationwide

34

24

0

Travelers

23

14

0

Progressive

18

35

1

American Family Insurance

5

5

0

Farmers

4

17

1

Framing classifies the wording used about a company in the selected answers. Positive wording does not by itself establish why a recommendation was or was not recorded, and neutral wording is not a negative signal. Net framing summarizes positive minus negative mentions across all mentions; it is not customer sentiment, satisfaction or a judgment of company quality.

Company results in detail

Lemonade

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about Lemonade mentions, recommendations and placement?

Lemonade ranks 1 by recommendation count. Mentions: 72 (90.00%); recommendations: 59 (73.75%). Top 3 placements: 41 (51.25%); first-place placements: 5 (6.25%).

Wording about the company: 60 positive, 12 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 81.9%. The net framing score was 0.83 (defined in Methodology).

13 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 69.49% were Top 3 and 8.47% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

Lemonade shares the top recommendation count with State Farm, supported by broad mention reach and mostly positive wording. Its recommendations were frequently placed in the shortlist, though first-place appearances were comparatively few. The gap between mentions and recommendations shows that appearing in an answer and being affirmatively endorsed are distinct outcomes in these records.

State Farm

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about State Farm mentions, recommendations and placement?

State Farm ranks 1 by recommendation count. Mentions: 80 (100.00%); recommendations: 59 (73.75%). Top 3 placements: 55 (68.75%); first-place placements: 25 (31.25%).

Wording about the company: 61 positive, 19 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 73.8%. The net framing score was 0.76 (defined in Methodology).

21 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 93.22% were Top 3 and 42.37% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

State Farm ties for the highest recommendation count while appearing in every qualified answer. Its recommendations were unusually likely to land in the shortlist and at first place, giving it a strong placement profile within its recommendation base. The mention-to-recommendation gap reflects answers that named the company without an affirmative endorsement.

USAA

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about USAA mentions, recommendations and placement?

USAA ranks 3 by recommendation count. Mentions: 76 (95.00%); recommendations: 56 (70.00%). Top 3 placements: 28 (35.00%); first-place placements: 10 (12.50%).

Wording about the company: 57 positive, 19 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 73.7%. The net framing score was 0.75 (defined in Methodology).

20 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 50.00% were Top 3 and 17.86% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

USAA sits just below the leading pair on recommendation count, with near-universal mention reach. Its recommendations were less often placed in the shortlist than the leaders', and first-place appearances were a modest subset. The profile shows strong presence alongside a more moderate placement pattern within recorded recommendations.

Amica

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about Amica mentions, recommendations and placement?

Amica ranks 4 by recommendation count. Mentions: 54 (67.50%); recommendations: 48 (60.00%). Top 3 placements: 33 (41.25%); first-place placements: 15 (18.75%).

Wording about the company: 48 positive, 6 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 88.9%. The net framing score was 0.89 (defined in Methodology).

6 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 68.75% were Top 3 and 31.25% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

Amica records fewer mentions than the leaders but a comparatively high share of its mentions carrying a recommendation, alongside a strongly positive framing balance. Its recommendations were often shortlisted and sometimes placed first. Because the mention base is smaller, the strong ratio should be read as a description of these answers rather than a stable property.

Allstate

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about Allstate mentions, recommendations and placement?

Allstate ranks 5 by recommendation count. Mentions: 72 (90.00%); recommendations: 37 (46.25%). Top 3 placements: 7 (8.75%); first-place placements: 0 (0.00%).

Wording about the company: 37 positive, 35 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 51.4%. The net framing score was 0.51 (defined in Methodology).

35 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 18.92% were Top 3 and 0.00% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

Allstate appeared in most qualified answers but carried a recommendation in only about half of them, and its framing was split between positive and neutral. Shortlist placements were rare and no first-place appearances were recorded. The contrast between wide mention reach and limited endorsement is the defining feature of this profile.

Nationwide

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about Nationwide mentions, recommendations and placement?

Nationwide ranks 6 by recommendation count. Mentions: 58 (72.50%); recommendations: 34 (42.50%). Top 3 placements: 3 (3.75%); first-place placements: 1 (1.25%).

Wording about the company: 34 positive, 24 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 58.6%. The net framing score was 0.59 (defined in Methodology).

24 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 8.82% were Top 3 and 2.94% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

Nationwide's mentions were common but recommendations less so, and its framing leaned positive with a substantial neutral share. Shortlist placements were few and first-place appearances minimal. The profile illustrates how a company can be present across many answers while seldom receiving an affirmative endorsement or a high position.

Travelers

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about Travelers mentions, recommendations and placement?

Travelers ranks 7 by recommendation count. Mentions: 37 (46.25%); recommendations: 23 (28.75%). Top 3 placements: 5 (6.25%); first-place placements: 2 (2.50%).

Wording about the company: 23 positive, 14 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 62.2%. The net framing score was 0.62 (defined in Methodology).

14 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 21.74% were Top 3 and 8.70% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

Travelers appeared in fewer than half of qualified answers, and its recommendations were a smaller subset still. Among recorded recommendations, shortlist and first-place placements were uncommon. Its framing was mostly positive where it appeared, but the limited mention base means the profile rests on comparatively few observations.

Progressive

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about Progressive mentions, recommendations and placement?

Progressive ranks 8 by recommendation count. Mentions: 54 (67.50%); recommendations: 18 (22.50%). Top 3 placements: 5 (6.25%); first-place placements: 0 (0.00%).

Wording about the company: 18 positive, 35 neutral, 1 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 33.3%. The net framing score was 0.31 (defined in Methodology).

36 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 27.78% were Top 3 and 0.00% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

Progressive was mentioned often but recommended in a minority of those mentions, and its framing was predominantly neutral with one negative mention. Shortlist placements were rare and no first-place appearances were recorded. The wide gap between appearance and endorsement distinguishes it from companies with similar mention totals.

American Family Insurance

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about American Family Insurance mentions, recommendations and placement?

American Family Insurance ranks 9 by recommendation count. Mentions: 10 (12.50%); recommendations: 5 (6.25%). Top 3 placements: 1 (1.25%); first-place placements: 0 (0.00%).

Wording about the company: 5 positive, 5 neutral, 0 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 50.0%. The net framing score was 0.50 (defined in Methodology).

5 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 20.00% were Top 3 and 0.00% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

American Family Insurance appeared in a small number of qualified answers, and recommendations were fewer still. Its framing was evenly split between positive and neutral, with a single shortlist placement and no first-place appearances. The sparse base means the ratios describe only these recorded answers and should not be generalized.

Farmers

Questions This Section Answers

  • What do the November 2026 AI answer results show about Farmers mentions, recommendations and placement?

Farmers ranks 10 by recommendation count. Mentions: 22 (27.50%); recommendations: 4 (5.00%). Top 3 placements: 0 (0.00%); first-place placements: 0 (0.00%).

Wording about the company: 4 positive, 17 neutral, 1 negative mentions. The proportion of mentions that also included a recommendation was 18.2%. The net framing score was 0.14 (defined in Methodology).

18 mentions had no recorded recommendation. Of recorded recommendations, 0.00% were Top 3 and 0.00% were first-place.

This edition establishes a broader research baseline. Earlier editions used a narrower set of questions, so their figures are not treated as a performance trend.

Farmers recorded a modest number of mentions, few recommendations and no shortlist or first-place placements. Its framing was mostly neutral, with one negative mention. The low share of mentions carrying a recommendation, on a small base, describes these answers only and does not establish why endorsement was absent.

Earlier ranking snapshot context

Questions This Section Answers

  • How do the available Renters Insurance snapshots from August 2026 to November 2026 differ in recommendation coverage and measurement scope?

Company

Nov 2026

Lemonade

59 / 80 (73.75%)

State Farm

59 / 80 (73.75%)

USAA

56 / 80 (70.00%)

Amica

48 / 80 (60.00%)

Allstate

37 / 80 (46.25%)

Nationwide

34 / 80 (42.50%)

Travelers

23 / 80 (28.75%)

Progressive

18 / 80 (22.50%)

American Family Insurance

5 / 80 (6.25%)

Farmers

4 / 80 (5.00%)

Company

Nov 2026 rank

Lemonade

1

State Farm

1

USAA

3

Amica

4

Allstate

5

Nationwide

6

Travelers

7

Progressive

8

American Family Insurance

9

Farmers

10

Only months with verified results are shown. Monthly sample coverage is listed in Methodology.

Only the November edition is shown here, and it establishes a broader baseline than earlier editions, which used a narrower question set. Counts and rates should be read together: a rate depends on the answer total, while a count reflects how many answers included the company. Earlier figures are not treated as a performance trend.

AI recommendation trend

Observed recommendation rate (%), Nov 2026

  • Lemonadeno change
    Nov 202673.8%
  • State Farmno change
    Nov 202673.8%
  • USAAno change
    Nov 202670.0%
  • Amicano change
    Nov 202660.0%
  • Allstateno change
    Nov 202646.3%
  • Nationwideno change
    Nov 202642.5%
  • Travelersno change
    Nov 202628.8%
  • Progressiveno change
    Nov 202622.5%
  • American Family Insuranceno change
    Nov 20266.3%
  • Farmersno change
    Nov 20265.0%

What the November Rankings Show

These measures answer separate questions. Mentions describe appearance, recommendations describe affirmative endorsement, placements describe position within recommendations, and framing describes wording. A company can be widely mentioned yet rarely endorsed, or endorsed often yet seldom placed first. The rankings summarize recorded AI answers, not customers, sales or verified product facts, and the ties and sparse bases limit firm ordering.

Methodology

Questions This Section Answers

  • How were the November 2026 Renters Insurance AI visibility measures counted, and what do they not establish?

Question-category coverage: 3 of 10 planned question categories contributed usable observations; 7 contributed none. This describes question-category coverage, not demonstrated platform outages. Findings apply to the available answer set. Mentions require the company to be identified in the answer; incidental uses of its name as an ordinary word are not counted. Mentions require the company to be identified in the answer; incidental uses of its name as an ordinary word are not counted.

The month in the title is the reporting period. The exact dates when the original AI answers were collected have not been verified.

Each company is counted at most once in each answer that meets the benchmark rules. A recommendation requires both an affirmative endorsement and positive wording. Mention, recommendation, Top 3 and first-place rates use the full benchmark answer total. Top 3 and first-place results are included within recommendations, not added to them.

The recommendation-to-mention ratio divides recommendations by mentions. It describes AI answer wording, not customer conversion. Net framing is positive minus negative mentions, divided by all mentions, on a scale from -1 to +1. It does not measure customer satisfaction or company quality.

Market: US; 10 tracked companies. AI services represented: ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity.

Research screening totals (answer observations can include repeated questions):

Screening measure

Count

Answers eligible for the limited email report

79

Answers marked relevant during screening

80

Answers marked reserved (screening label)

1

Answers marked irrelevant during screening

720

Captured answer observations

800

Distinct questions

645

Answer observations marked as mentioning a brand

800

Email eligibility and reservation labels do not limit this article: all relevant captured answers are included in its rate denominator.

One answer can mention or recommend several companies. Adding company totals would therefore count some answers more than once. The results describe the AI answers reviewed, not independently verified facts about the companies or their products.

Monthly sample coverage:

Reporting month

Answers included

AI services covered

Services

Nov 2026

80

6

ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity

Earlier editions (August 2026, September 2026 and October 2026) used a narrower set of questions. This edition includes all captured answers screened as relevant and establishes a broader baseline. Earlier figures remain in the archive; they are not used to claim a change in performance.

Future editions using the same screening scope can be compared against this baseline.

Findings apply only to the available answer set, and question-category coverage was partial. Each company is counted at most once per qualifying answer, and one answer can name several companies, so company totals overlap. Recommendation-to-mention ratios describe answer wording, not customer conversion, and net framing is not a measure of satisfaction or quality. The exact collection dates were not verified.

Archived editions

Browse earlier published research snapshots for this article. The latest edition remains at the current URL.